He would win in New Jersey and Montreal, but that's it. Outside of those two cities most people bash Marty for being a goalie only as good as his luck and the defense in front of him. Everywhere I've lived (both coasts and in the heartland) there was never a clear liking of Brodeur. It's jealousy, of course, but it shows that he would lose a popularity contest. He deserved Vezinas when Roy was still playing and when Hasek was at or near his prime, but didn't get it because of popularity. Marty deserved the Conn Smythe in 2003, but lost to Jiggy-puff because of popularity.
It's better for the league if Queen Henrik wins, because most of America blindly likes New York teams regardless of how awful the franchise is run.