It may be important to note that they've set an additional criterion of a minimum of 200 games played with the franchise. Surprisingly, this does not disqualify Kovalchuk but it does leave out such names as Sean Burke, Sheldon Souray, Chico, Jeff Friesen, and Steve Thomas.
If you're going with the best cohesive line, I think you have to pick Elias, Sykora, and Arnott. If you're cherry-picking the best players available regardless of chemistry or even time period, I would choose Elias, Parise, and Gomez. (I initially said MacLean instead of Gomez, but then I realized that left me without a center, even though HockeyDB says Parise's a center. Was he drafted as a center?)
IMO, the back three are fairly obvious: Stevens, Niedermayer, and Brodeur.
Edited by RowdyFan42, 08 August 2013 - 12:19 PM.