Holy christ could people understand that (at least) my objection, and most of the other objections expressed in this thread, have little to do with profanity? It has to do with celebrating a goal by mocking the other team. It'd basically be inexplicable to someone you were explaining sports to, or indeed, even someone you were bringing to a Devils game for the first time. 'Okay, now when the Devils score a goal, they do this chant, 'you suck' - but it's directed at the other team.' 'So, the other team sucks for giving up a goal to the Devils? Doesn't that mean the Devils suck too, by implication? I mean, if you suck for having given up a goal to them, then they probably suck too' 'No, no, they're great, it's complicated, it's tradition'
I understand that point of view but I feel like you are really over-analyzing the situation.
I honestly don't care what the Devils pick as long as it gets people to stop complaining about "you suck" and gives the fans something to either clap or sing along to which from what I can tell this Bon Jovi song doesn't. I think a fan vote online would be the way to go.