I can't believe you are saying my theory is insane after everything that has happened with the goalie situation this season.
I am not saying if Cory wins and Brodeur loses, he won't get the next star. I am saying Cory needs an excellent game to get a look at the next game after Tampa. If Cory wins 3-2 and Brodeur wins 4-3, who gets the next game? What about if Cory wins 3-0 and Brodeur wins 4-2?
I think yeah in that case Brodeur gets the next start, but I think Cory would get the next start after that one regardless of what happened with Brodeur.