I'm not talking about him creating offense as much as I'm talking about him disrupting the other team's offense. For example the Kings game, I think if Marty plays, they probably don't win. But if he does play, I don't think they look nearly as bad as they looked. For a team that passes as poorly as we do, getting hemmed up is a death sentence
For teams able to carry the puck into the zone, Brodeur does exactly nothing to help in the defensive zone.