I'm still waiting for Martin to carry an average team on his back to a cup final as Roy did TWICE (1986 & 1993) while standing on his head and facing a barrage of shots.
Im fine with rewarding Roy for outstanding performances on average teams, but how can you criticize a guy for being great while having great guys around him? did Marty choose to have stevens/niedermayer around for a decade? he's done an okay job since they left with Colin White and Paul Martin as the cornerpieces of the D.
The only thing that might put Roy ahead of Marty is the fact that he managed to win a cup with Lyle Odelein, a feat Marty never accomplished.