Your Elias was clean? My 11-12 Set 2 white has some good puck/stick marks throughout but no repairs. I've seen some other Elias gamers and they usually have at least decent wear on them.
I have 2 Greene gamers and both have little to no wear. One is a one game wonder so naturally it has almost no wear but the other I have is a 08-09 gamer ( I believe set 1 and he wore a size 54 then) and that has very little to no wear. I find that interesting since he is a defenseman (though admittedly he didn't play as many minutes that year).
I have an Elias 09-10 Red Set 2 and Greene 11-12 White Set 3 and both are really clean. The Greene jersey is particularly surprising considering his style of play and that it was from the 11-12 playoff run.
I had an 11-12 Zubrus and there were tons of repairs/marks on it. Made me respect him even more as a player.