As bad as he looked last year, I'm not ready to throw in the towel on Ryder.
Dude has 5 seasons of scoring 25+ goals.
His 2011 season was very similar in points to last year, and he followed that season with a 35 goal output.
He was pretty snake-bit last year, so I'm willing to give him another chance. Brunner doesn't have the track record of Ryder, and was signed out of necessity last year.
He just doesn't fit the system though. He skates worse than anyone I've ever seen and is just all around crap besides his shot, which is really good. Brunner gave us practically the same amount of ppg as Ryder did, costs $1M less, is younger and faster.