Craig Rivet. Dave Andreychuk in his final NHL season. I think Gary Roberts was a captain somewhere when he was terrible too. Lyle Odelein might've been a captain in Columbus, I forget. Those are just off the top of my head, I think there are other candidates, especially on expansion teams (was Brad Marsh Ottawa's first captain or was it Laurie Boschman?)
Problem is that we're not an expansion team.