As much as it kills me to say it, Roy probably has been the better goalie in his peaks. Nothing Brodeur has done can really compete with the 86 cup where he basically won the cup single handedly. He also outduled Brodeur in 2001, although they were both inconsistent throughout the series. That said, you could definitely make an argument that Brodeur has been the more consistent goalie. He has continued to improve over his career while Roy has been inconsistent at times.