Jump to content

HHOF Class of 2013 Thread


devilsrule33

HHOF 2013  

57 members have voted

  1. 1. Who do you think should be part of the HHOF Class of 2013

    • Dave Andreychuk
      11
    • Rob Blake
      2
    • Rod Brind'Amour
      7
    • Chris Chelios
      35
    • Vincent Damphousse
      1
    • Theo Fleury
      3
    • Phil Housley
      3
    • Paul Kariya
      9
    • Alex Mogilny
      12
    • Scott Niedermayer
      51
    • Jeremy Roenick
      11
    • Brendan Shanahan
      46
    • Keith Tkachuk
      8
    • Pierre Turgeon
      2
    • Sergei Zubov
      2
    • Curtis Joseph
      4
    • Mike Vernon
      0
    • PAT BURNS
      37
    • Eric Lindros
      11


Recommended Posts

Chelios, Shanahan and Niedermayer should be locks...Mogilny on the cusp though he probably won't get in. To be honest I'm not 100% sold on Niedermayer either, but no question he had hall of fame talent.

 

Richter is not a hall of famer

 

Burns deserves to go in

 

Lindros...too many injuries. Andreychuk will be viewed as a compiler. 

 

Outside of 1990-1994 Roenicks numbers are very ordinary

 

Fleury would be a good bet if he didn't screw things up himself. He was on a hall of fame pace pre substance issues

Edited by '7'
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chelios, Shanahan and Niedermayer should be locks...Mogilny on the cusp though he probably won't get in. To be honest I'm not 100% sold on Niedermayer either, but no question he had hall of fame talent.

 

Richter is not a hall of famer

 

Burns deserves to go in

 

Lindros...too many injuries. Andreychuk will be viewed as a compiler. 

 

Outside of 1990-1994 Roenicks numbers are very ordinary

 

Fleury would be a good bet if he didn't screw things up himself. He was on a hall of fame pace pre substance issues

 

The case for Lindros has been made twofold:  He did have a streak of short-term dominance, and with some of the other names that have gotten in (like Bure and Neely), he should go too. 

 

re: Andreychuk, his career really breaks down into three distinct stages, as far as his offensive production goes.  He's also one of those guys that played in both the Live and Dead Puck Eras, so that should be taken into account when splitting his career up:

 

'82-'94:  877 GP, 908 Pts, 1.03 P/GP

'94-'97:  206 GP, 156 Pts, 0.76 P/GP

'97-'06:  556 GP, 274 Pts, 0.49 P/GP

 

If Andreychuk had retired after the '97 season, he finishes with 1083 GP and 1064 points (503 goals and 561 assists)...this is Joe Mullen territory (1062 GP, 502 G, 561 A, 1063 points), who went in with the 2000 class. Only 22 players have reached 500 goals in less games (Andreychuk did it in his 1070th game).  That body of work should probably be enough to get him in, though just about all of his more productive seasons came during Live Puck.  But he managed to stick around and still be an effective, though much less statistically dynamic, player for eight more seasons and 556 more games.  Should he be penalized for that, for being willing to make adjustments in his game and become a different kind of player?  I don't know.      

Edited by Colorado Rockies 1976
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Chelios

Niedermayer

Shanahan

Geraldine Heaney

Fred Shero

 

 

Three ex-Devils :devil: : Brendan Shanahan, Scott Niedermayer and ...

 

... Fred Shero, Devils radio color analyst for the team's first five years!

 

Congrats to all!!!   :thumbsup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.