Jump to content

On Lou Lamoriello's Failure To Construct A Decent 23 Man Roster


Triumph

Recommended Posts

Pete Deboer is quoted by TG today saying this: "I’ve got to do a better job of getting our fourth line involved and getting them some minutes.” Yeah, great. Except that you've got Eric Boulton, who's about halfway a hockey player and is quickly turning into not a hockey player at all, and Cam Janssen who has never been confused with a man capable of playing professional hockey at a competent level, on that line. Teams have been consistently getting one of their top 2 lines against this line with predictable results. Now you might be asking - well, why aren't there any other forwards on this team? Because Lou screwed up, that's why.

It's a little known rule, but after the trade deadline, a team is only allowed 4 non-emergency recalls from their minor league team. This rule covers both the regular season and the playoffs - if the Albany Devils are out of the playoffs and the New Jersey Devils make the playoffs, you'll see the Devils use all of their recalls after the final day of the AHL season. I don't think Lou is willing to recall a player in a non-emergency only to send him down a few days later. He will have wasted a recall by doing so.

So you might be thinking, well then, why doesn't he use emergency recall? Well, you can only use emergency recall if your team goes below 12 healthy forwards. The Devils have 12 healthy forwards - it's just that one of them is Cam Janssen, who's a forward in quotes.

4th lines ultimately don't mean that much, but the Devils have yet to have a goal scored while their entire 4th line was out on the ice, while they've had several goals scored against them. They've made their 4th line mean as much as it possibly can. AHL playoffs be damned, get Zharkov or Zalewski or Wiseman or someone up here who can play at a competent NHL level.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 62
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

i don't disagree with this at all. remember in january, it was not just the 4th line, but the 3rd line that was awful. Lou addressed that with Ponikarovski and Bernier. They've tried to fill a 4th line w/ AHL filler and two goons - something you wrote well about on the blog yesterday.

i do think lou has been holding out hope that zajac's return would create a 4th line of carter-josefson-boulton which isn't entirely awful.

all that being said, zharkov should absolutely be up here. the 4th line is about giving other lines a rest more than anything else. it should at worst be as little a liability as possible. zharkov was NEVER considered a liability when he played. he might have provided little to no offense, but he wasn't out there with a target on his chest for opposing forwards to tee off on and attack.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Although i agree cam and boulton are not the best hockey players, they are 4th liners their job is to bang bodies and pump up the team with fighting when neccesary, i do agree they could contribute a lot more offensively and we don't need both on the 4th line as they both effectively do the same job but i do think your being harsh on the pair. Cam is only a -8 ok boulton is a -12 but clarky is a -11 so dont think you can read too much into that. When zajac comes back i dont think you will see at least one of them in the lineup anyway.

Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Although i agree cam and boulton are not the best hockey players, they are 4th liners their job is to bang bodies and pump up the team with fighting when neccesary, i do agree they could contribute a lot more offensively and we don't need both on the 4th line as they both effectively do the same job but i do think your being harsh on the pair. Cam is only a -8 ok boulton is a -12 but clarky is a -11 so dont think you can read too much into that. When zajac comes back i dont think you will see at least one of them in the lineup anyway.

Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk

boulton is a -12 in only 266 minutes of even strength hockey. clarkson has played 865 minutes of even strength hockey, were he to produce the same rate of minuses, he'd be -39. and that's ignoring that a lot of clarkson's minuses have come while on the power play or with the net empty - he's only -3 at even strength.

now boulton's got his share of bad luck - 80 shots on goal by the devils without a goal while he's been on the ice - but at some point the puck has to go in the net.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, the fourth line was victimized against the Isles when Okposo scored. They are definitely costing us some points and something needs to be done. When they are on the ice, one of three things always happens:

1. They are scored on

2. They ice the puck, causing a dangerous defensive draw

3. They are pinned in our zone and constantly fail to clear the puck

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Although i agree cam and boulton are not the best hockey players, they are 4th liners their job is to bang bodies and pump up the team with fighting when neccesary, i do agree they could contribute a lot more offensively and we don't need both on the 4th line as they both effectively do the same job but i do think your being harsh on the pair. Cam is only a -8 ok boulton is a -12 but clarky is a -11 so dont think you can read too much into that. When zajac comes back i dont think you will see at least one of them in the lineup anyway.

Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk

Janssen's like a joke that's not funny anymore. It's a miracle he's actually got 303 NHL games under his belt. And the Cam staged-fight thing has gotten old too. I'll never mind fights that happen with good reason, but the whole "neither one of us can do anything else, so let's fight" nonsense is lame.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Janssen's like a joke that's not funny anymore. It's a miracle he's actually got 303 NHL games under his belt. And the Cam staged-fight thing has gotten old too. I'll never mind fights that happen with good reason, but the whole "neither one of us can do anything else, so let's fight" nonsense is lame.

and its not like he's even dominated fights this year... like what gives??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

and its not like he's even dominated fights this year... like what gives??

Did he ever, really? I know he's fearless (or just stupid), but I don't ever remember him being some kind of a fighting beast.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Did he ever, really? I know he's fearless (or just stupid), but I don't ever remember him being some kind of a fighting beast.

His bouts with Hollweg and Tucker are among my all-time favorite hockey fights. Hollweg in particular was a total asswhooping. Which was rare for Cam, considering how he rarely finds opponents in his own weight class.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For now Lou has the points cushion to keep the 4th line intact, but that cushion is shrinking rapidly with this slide we're on and he may soon have to recall Zharkov and others if it continues, like you say Tri. But as long as we have this cushion, and Zajac is on the horizon, he won't do a thing until the AHL season is over, and I don't think you can blame him. We all say "AHL be damned", but it is actually important to the organization that they perform as well as they can.

However, I actually AM very excited about our playoff roster since I'm pretty sure that between Zajac, Zharkov and Tedenby (I hope), we should be able to field a decent 4 lines.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i am in no way defending having both of these guys on the roster and it's almost negligent that they be in the lineup together, but cam is a very well liked guy in the clubhouse and a fan favorite. keep in mind, this is still entertainment and fans clearly want to see janssen.

#freezharkov

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't need goons anymore. Look at Detroit. Make your statement in pucks in net not in punches to the face.

Hear Hear! Those pathetic fights are not even remotely close to entertaining anyway. Try embarrassing and annoying.

It's utterly ridiculous that these players (Janssen, Boulton, Mills) are ever on the team. We could easily replace the entire 4th line with 100% superior players from europe for less then a $1M cap hit. (Granted, maybe not on two-way contracts.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pete Deboer is quoted by TG today saying this: "I’ve got to do a better job of getting our fourth line involved and getting them some minutes.” Yeah, great. Except that you've got Eric Boulton, who's about halfway a hockey player and is quickly turning into not a hockey player at all, and Cam Janssen who has never been confused with a man capable of playing professional hockey at a competent level, on that line. Teams have been consistently getting one of their top 2 lines against this line with predictable results. Now you might be asking - well, why aren't there any other forwards on this team? Because Lou screwed up, that's why.

It's a little known rule, but after the trade deadline, a team is only allowed 4 non-emergency recalls from their minor league team. This rule covers both the regular season and the playoffs - if the Albany Devils are out of the playoffs and the New Jersey Devils make the playoffs, you'll see the Devils use all of their recalls after the final day of the AHL season. I don't think Lou is willing to recall a player in a non-emergency only to send him down a few days later. He will have wasted a recall by doing so.

So you might be thinking, well then, why doesn't he use emergency recall? Well, you can only use emergency recall if your team goes below 12 healthy forwards. The Devils have 12 healthy forwards - it's just that one of them is Cam Janssen, who's a forward in quotes.

4th lines ultimately don't mean that much, but the Devils have yet to have a goal scored while their entire 4th line was out on the ice, while they've had several goals scored against them. They've made their 4th line mean as much as it possibly can. AHL playoffs be damned, get Zharkov or Zalewski or Wiseman or someone up here who can play at a competent NHL level.

Yes sir we need somewhat of scoring spark there....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Parise-Kovalchuk-Henrique

Sykora-Elias-Zubrus

Poni-Zajac-Clarkson

Bernier-Josefson-Carter

I don't know what we're talking about here.. That's the point of all of Lou's recent moves.. we now have 4 real lines

You can switch around some of the players around on my lines 3 and 4... we still have all legit NHL players... Lou knew what he was doing

There's no Boulton, Janssen or Mills on my playoff starting roster

Link to comment
Share on other sites

pull all the goons and watch us get roughed up and not score, happened when Henrique "fought" Iginla

im not is disagreement and im not saying tedy is the answer

start zajac on the 4th line and let him work it out

i just cant understand how fighting is not part of the game

two great fights vs the rags after we were already up, not a great time but defenitly a factor in the series

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.