Jump to content

Shanahan joins Devils


jkrdevil

Recommended Posts

Mogilny 89

Gilmour 93

Tererri 31

There's more. Only goalies though with numbers 30-40

How could you forget REID SIMPSON #33

As to Shanahan, I think it's just the first step before Lou makes that blockbuster with San Jose to reacquire Claude Lemieux.

Edited by halfsharkalligatorhalfman
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 240
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

And you're absolutely on drugs if you think Gionta is going to give up #14 for a 4th liner....

And you're on drugs if you seriously think what line a player is on has anything to do with giving up uniform numbers. If you want to get technical, Zubrus gave up his # to a 4th liner who isn't a future HOF'er as Shanahan is.

Having said that, Shanahan isn't getting 14, but it's not due to him being a "4th liner".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep. but its funny how age can easily become an issue as the season grinds on into the playoffs. Besides, Chelios screws up that average anyway :lol:

Funny but absolutely true. Cheli skews the data for Detroit. Bet if you took him out of the numbers, we'd be No. 1 in age.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not going to jump for joy on this just yet. He may be Brendan Shanahan but he is an aged Shanahan. No one I think will argue his best years were spent on the Wings HOWEVER I was just checking his stats over the course of the last 3 seasons and they are not terrible. I think he will do pretty well for himself and afterall he's Brendan Shanahan so anythings possible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i just hope he rocks this team just as igor larionov did a couple years back.

now THAT was a signing.

wait a minute, you're forgetting valerie kaminski?? talk about a player that put us over the "edge"

the signing of this old tool sent a message to the bergfors of the world, you won't be coming up this year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Haven't posted all season, felt this was a good topic to weigh in on.

Personally, I like the move. Shanahan getting 4th line minutes, PP and PK minutes, will be more effective then any of the "future stars" in Lowell that many folks on this board are longing for. That unconditional love for those kids makes me scratch my head. Brendan Shanahan at 40 blows away ANY option on the farm. Unfortunately, many here go ga-ga over names like Bergfors. Is it because he was a first rounder? I digress.

As far as who comes out of the lineup? I think Madden's days are numbered on this roster. If that's not the plan, then in my eyes, Pando is forward #13.

For anyone who thinks Rupper comes out, last night is the perfect reason he doesn't.

Greene levels Parise=Rupp pounds Greene.

The Devils have MANY willing fighters who do a great job, but Rupper is a heavyweight. Never thought I'd say that, but he has really impressed this season.

This has been my favorite Devils team in years, 'cause they have an edge they haven't had since having Oliwa. With fighting up BIG TIME, and it not going away any time soon, the fact that he does what he does, AND, he can play the game, not only do you keep him in the lineup, but I think he gets a long, hard look as a re-sign this summer.

Of course, my version of "can play" doesn't mean he's only 22, and has 30 goal potential with first line minutes, as it seems many here want as a requirement to be on this roster.

One more thing, do people need to get on Sheldon friggin Brookbank at all times? He's a spare part, and when called upon, he does fine as said spare part. Geez.

People need to enjoy this team more! They're not going 82-0. They are not pitching 82 shutouts. They will not have 8 30 goal scorers. They will not field a lineup of nothing but 22 year old first round picks. No one is winning the Norris. Brent Sutter is here for the long haul. Sheldon Brookbank is what he is, and despite no big names, our D is doing a pretty damn good job! Just enjoy a scrappy team who has some great nights, and has some bad nights. Let's face it folks, in the end, we'll be in the dance, with just as much potential to do damage as everyone else.

Edited by davemaleyfan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not thrilled...I realize the team basically needs to score 3 to win until Brodeur gets back and that the offense hasn't been consistent the last several games (good-bad-awful-good-awful-awful-good-etc) so they had to do something, but I'm not sure this was it.

I guess the theory is that Shanahan has been most useful in the first half of the season the last few years (and he'll only be playing one half of a season) and he's really most useful on the PP. That may be true - but that means he has to actually want to be here, and I'm not sure that's true, I think he wanted to sign with the Rangers and gave up hope, and it also means that, essentially, NJ will be giving a regular shift to a guy who is now a PP specialist.

I have great respect for Shanahan. He had a fantastic career. But it worries me to sign a guy who spent several months hoping that the team across the river would sign him and 'settled' for NJ and who would also be taking up a regular shift when he is now a PP specialist.

NJ is a team you have to really want to play for - or you don't play here. Holik was definitely right about that, much as it pains me to say it. And as much as the PP needs help (despite the inability of the Kings to kill penalties last night), a guy who is really here as a PP specialist isn't necessarily going to fit in with a team that has just deliberately moved to strategy of rolling 4 lines (away from matching and giving the checking line more time at the expense of the 'top' lines).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't get some people's conjecture that Rupp is the odd man out. If the Devils are running a hockey team and not a seniority list, the odd man out should be Jay Pandolfo, pending another move by Lamoriello.

agreed and i think rupp has played very well this season. hell, rupp has played better than bobby holik, who has somehow earned carte blanche around here 'cause every once in a while he lays some guy out, even though he takes dumb penalty after dumb penalty.

the sports nerd is officially excited that shanahan will be a devil (again), in the same way that i was excited that valeri kamensky would be a devil.

another thing that has to be looked at re: shanahan's fatigue and awfulness in the playoffs is that he was playing 20 minutes a game 2 years ago and 18:30 last season. i mean, sh!t, zach parise doesn't play that many minutes. so i think as a 13-15 minute player he will be more effective.

one thing that does worry me is what sue said, though - he doesn't seem 100% committed to new jersey. from that interview it sounds more like shanny isn't looking forward to taking the metaphorical PATH train - i'd like it a lot more if he said something silly and unprofessional like that he wanted to get back at sather and the rangers.

Edited by Triumph
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those I loved then hated can be loved again.....maybe

Shanny was the only Ranger I could stand last year -- he tried to stop some of Avery's sh!t

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I mean clearly the team isn't old enough without Shanahan.
http://njdevs.com/forums/style_images/...link-button.png

I wouldn't love being an old team, but Marty's not young, they need to build for right now and win while we still have the best goalie ever. Shanny's still got some game, if not for long.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This movie confirms that Lou is really going for it this year though, which I've said from the beginning. This is a win-now team.

What move could possibly make sense that wouldn't show the Devils were going for it this year? In fact, I would speculate there are many moves that Lou could do that would be more win-now than a move like this is. The Devils sacrificed no future pieces for this move while they could sacrifice future pieces for rental players, as an example.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One more thing, do people need to get on Sheldon friggin Brookbank at all times? He's a spare part, and when called upon, he does fine as said spare part. Geez.

I completely agree. I may not ever want to see Brookbank in the lineup, but he's a class act who always plays hard and never complains about playing time. Whether or not he should be in Jersey, he's done nothing to merit us going after him -- he's not getting paid much, and he's never pretended to be a superstar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One more thing, do people need to get on Sheldon friggin Brookbank at all times? He's a spare part, and when called upon, he does fine as said spare part. Geez.

Where was anyone "getting on" him? All I've seen in this thread were rational trade considerations?

Edited by RunninWithTheDevil
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.